Bulletin N°65 2026 The documentary Naza, applauded and awarded at the Venice Film Festival, was condemned by Zionist politicians.
Presented at the Venice Film Festival , the documentary film Naza (meaning collateral damage) by Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, financed in part by the British newspaper The Guardian, received a tremendous ovation: more than 20 minutes of applause after its screening at the Venice Film Festival, and the Special Jury Prize. The film is based on interviews with members of the Israeli Army. The faces of the twenty-four interviewees remain blurred, and their voices have been altered. The interviews took place discreetly, in the dim light, on a terrace overlooking the city.
A journalist from 20minutes , who saw the film, wrote: “ The testimonies of those interviewed are appallingly natural and straightforward. We discover that the Israeli army considers a 15% margin of error in the number of people killed acceptable and that it is legitimate to kill suspected terrorists at night in the midst of their families, including wives and children. What is said is astounding. One of the soldiers compares the strikes to a video game, and another admits to having enjoyed shooting Palestinians trying to reach supply points. These men are not monsters. Between the dehumanization inherent in drone attacks and a carefully cultivated hatred, they carry out their duty without much remorse. They even end up admitting to having killed innocent people, knowing that they were neither armed nor threatening. ”
Among politicians of all stripes within the Zionist colonial entity, the film and the award it received sparked outrage. Culture Minister Miki Zohar spoke out on September 13th, declaring: “ The filmmakers’ burning self-hatred, their willingness to harm their homeland in order to receive applause from anti-Semites worldwide, is incomprehensible and constitutes treason against the State. ” That same evening, he demanded that the two filmmakers be stripped of their citizenship. Regarding the opposition coalition to Netanyahu, the “liberal Zionists,” the ultra-reactionary Avigdor Lieberman, former Defense Minister, denounced “a web of defamation and slander against the State of Israel, against the IDF, and against our magnificent fighters .”
Rachel Szor, director, and Yuval Abraham, investigative journalist who has ventured into documentary filmmaking, are also the authors, in 2024, of the film No Other Land, showing the reality of the pressure of the colonial occupation on the Palestinians of the West Bank, through the village of Massafer Yata, the demolitions of houses by the Zionist colonial state, the arbitrary arrests, the murders, and the resistance of the Palestinians rebuilding the destroyed houses at night.
We could end there and join the chorus of praise and those who consider Abraham and Szor as heroes, but the reality shown by this film and the analysis that can be made of the event at the Venice Film Festival are much more complex.
The validation of a crime by the criminals
The enthusiastic audiences at the Venice Film Festival and the people celebrating the two "heroes," particularly the unanimous "left" in France, perfectly illustrate the problem. In concrete terms, a film made by citizens of the Zionist entity has made the Palestinian reality credible enough to be confronted. Simply because an Israeli says so. Today, the film is celebrated because Zionist soldiers recount the details of the murder of Palestinians. We didn't experience such fervor or emotion when Palestinians recounted these same details, when the inhabitants of Gaza filmed their children under the rubble and their doctors amputating the wounded without anesthesia. Western self-righteousness hasn't really reacted to the considerable mass of images and testimonies documenting the annihilation of entire families and the murder of journalists while they were reporting the truth. Judging by these enthusiastic reactions, one might conclude that there was a need for a voice from within the occupying army itself to confirm the reality of what has been happening for three years in plain sight. What moral failing leads to suspending the credibility of a victim's testimony until it is validated by a member of their oppressor's army?
We are undeniably witnessing a denial of the Palestinians, since the Venice Film Festival doesn't show their own suffering, filmed by them , but only the perspective, however criticized, of the occupying colonial army. Moreover, there were two Palestinian films at the festival, including "Citizen Osama," by Ahmed Hassouna, a Palestinian director from Gaza. The official synopsis of his documentary reads: " In Gaza, between the bombings and his dreams of cinema, a journalist navigates between professional duty, family anxieties, and the emotion of becoming a father, striving to preserve what remains of humanity in a world plunged into chaos. " However, "Citizen Osama" was selected only out of competition at the Venice Film Festival ; neither the director nor the actors were able to attend.
A large part of the Western ideological petty bourgeoisie cannot or will not believe the Palestinian narrative, labeling them terrorists, Islamists, and anti-Semites, and only lends credence to it when "good guys" from the Zionist colonial "democracy" validate it. This is the harsh reality that the Venice Film Festival confronts us with . And it's not new. We need only recall Waltz with Bashir , released in 2008. This title referred to a scene where a Zionist soldier fired while dancing in the heart of Beirut, surrounded by portraits of Bachir Gemayel, the Zionist enemy's ally in Lebanon! The film revisited the invasion of Lebanon and the Sabra and Shatila massacres through the memories, nightmares, and remorse—poor man—of this IDF soldier. He naturally won a Golden Globe in 2009, awarded to the Zionist colonial state, the very same one that perpetrated these massacres in Lebanon!
The Zionists benefit from this.
With the film Naza and its harrowing testimonies about the crimes of the occupation, the same question resurfaces regarding the meaning of this fascination. And what are its consequences? The blood of Palestinians and Lebanese is relegated to the background behind the psychological crisis of a soldier who participated in the invasion, the genocide, the killings, the bulldozing, and the mutilations. Ultimately, his moral conscience takes center stage, and his confession becomes an achievement worthy of awards and enthusiastic applause. Certainly, revealing the crime can serve the truth. But transforming this into a celebration of Zionist conscience allows the colonial state to accumulate moral capital and the colonial entity to polish its image, while the rights of the victims remain suspended or are forgotten. Thus, the Occupation manages to absorb the condemnation of its crimes and present it as proof of its capacity for self-criticism, without, however, questioning its foundations. This is his work, this film he produced. The courage of this confession does not grant the state a certificate of innocence; at best, it earns them another film award. Palestinian and Arab blood cannot be used to polish the image of the occupation!
These testimonies can certainly provide evidence for accountability, but transforming this confession into an act of moral bravery, while concealing the identities of those involved, amounts to celebrating them while absolving them of all responsibility. Palestinian blood cannot be used to rehabilitate the image of those who shed it. Everything we observe about this film places the Zionists at the center of everything. The film presents the war crimes of the Zionist colonial entity against the Palestinians in such a way that it refuses to humanize them. Because we barely see them.
An internet user posted this message on X: “ Two settlers record interviews with genocidal settlers to get them to testify about how they exterminated indigenous Palestinians, while guaranteeing their anonymity to protect them from potential trials and imprisonment. A standing ovation at the Venice Film Festival. Israel has created a specific film genre, ‘ Shoot and Cry , ’ based on the psychological shock felt by Israeli soldiers after killing Palestinians or Lebanese. ” We are once again at the heart of the problem. Because this “film genre,” as described, transforms the perpetrators of genocide into traumatized victims of a colonial system that is never questioned. All these poignant films are acclaimed and awarded prizes at Western film festivals, like Naza in Venice. These Western imperialist countries, by rewarding these works of propaganda, support the Zionists’ substitute colonialism. They all try to make us believe that the elimination of the natives was inevitable, while pretending to have felt uneasy about it, as in Waltz with Bashir.
Or perhaps they suggest the existence of a fringe of settlers opposed to these "excesses," and that colonization must be more "humanitarian"; that a part of colonial society demonstrates humanity, like the filmmakers of Naza . The film can thus be interpreted as "There is a reality of anti-Zionist resistance within the colonial entity ," which is a lie, and all those praising the film know it. But the message is this: "There is hope within Zionist colonial society; therefore, the colonial entity can and must be rehabilitated." In reality, the society of the colonial entity is riddled with Zionism, and the two filmmakers serve, at best, as tokens. Among these settlers, whoever they may be, a humanity is ultimately recognized, unlike the exterminated indigenous people, who are not considered human beings and therefore do not deserve to have the spokespeople of Western imperialists hold out a microphone to them to recount their own extermination. For three years, no Western journalist or filmmaker has penetrated the vast death ghetto that is Gaza, and no "humanitarian Zionist" has produced an epic film about the Gaza ghetto uprising, unlike what has been done for the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising or the German extermination camps. The objective of this "cinematic genre" is to allow the continuation of extermination and ethnic cleansing by offering a disguise based on the self-victimization of both soldiers and some settlers.
Finally, it also serves to absolve Zionists. Naza also fulfills a crucial propaganda function: it allows Zionists, fully aware of what their genocidal entity was doing and supporting it wholeheartedly, to feign shock and sudden discovery, while simultaneously realizing the brand's tarnished image. It transforms them, superficially, into "moral" beings. For example, the Zionist TV presenter, Raviv Drucker, watched the film. He commented that he saw himself " like Germans during the Second World War discovering what their country had done. "
The summary of Naza and his projection is as follows: he doesn't name names, therefore no accusations can be made against any individual who actively participated in the genocide; he reveals, with great fanfare, what everyone has known for ages; and finally, he is a way of extending compassion to those who commit genocide. As if they didn't already receive far more empathy than their victims!
The ambiguity of Yuval Abraham
In April 2024, Yuval Abraham was among the many "left-wing" intellectuals within Zionist colonial society who spread lies about rapes allegedly perpetrated by the Resistance. The staunchly pro-Zionist New York Times, as we know, had to throw in the towel after a four-month investigation in March 2024, revealing that it had found no evidence. Undeterred, the media of the Zionist colonial state attempted to get former captives of the Palestinian Resistance to speak out, one of whom vaguely fulfilled this role after remaining silent for several weeks. Here is the content of Yuval Abraham's message: " The silence of those who spent months sowing doubt about Israeli rape testimonies is shameful. Today, when a courageous hostage describes in detail how she was chained and sexually tortured, it is equally shameful." Those who exploit these facts to justify crimes in Gaza are equally guilty. Propagandists, all of them… .” Like other Zionists, he amplified fabricated lies about rapes perpetrated by Palestinians that never actually occurred. These lies contributed to plunging the public of the Zionist colonial entity into a genocidal frenzy, further exacerbating their bloodlust, and served up a ready-made pretext for Western “progressives” to stand idly by and do nothing. The very purpose of this mass rape hoax was for these Western “progressives” to perceive genocide as a justified punishment. It was all a lie, and Yuval Abraham helped to legitimize it.
Yuval Abraham himself served in the colonial occupation army. And, in all his publications, he framed the context in a degrading light, placing the occupier and the occupied people on equal footing in their condemnation, while admittedly acknowledging the existence of the occupation. He is like our "good-hearted" colonialists in France, who vilify Netanyahu (but not Zionism) and Hamas, treating colonizer and colonized alike. This approach cannot contribute to the end of colonization.
Finally, upon the release of No Other Land , Abraham claimed to be interconnected with the Palestinian actors and their village. Since then, several villagers have been abducted, a Palestinian assistant director was murdered by the occupying army, the village has seen increased destruction, and, in his second film, there are no Palestinians at all. Where does this "interconnectedness" end?
In conclusion
Beneath every rock highlighted by the colonialist "left" of good intentions and the petty bourgeoisie, there's a hidden eel. And this one is a big one!
The validation three years later, when a settler speaks the truth, by all the self-righteous "leftists" might seem surprising. Yet it stems from their difficulty, even their inability, to grasp the reality of colonization. For them, Zionist colonial society is a "normal" society, a "democracy," as Sophie Binet would say. However, while it is a bourgeois democracy, and not a true democracy like Western imperialist countries, it is impossible to forget that it is distinct because it is a settler society, and that colonial identity has a very specific character. Within the framework of a colonialism based on the forced demographic replacement of indigenous populations by foreign settlers, the latter develop their own mode of capital accumulation—in terms of land, resources, or the exploitation of indigenous labor—during the process of invasion. This is a distinct form of wealth accumulation, specific to both the settler society and the individuals themselves, in addition to that which benefits the metropolis from the existence and operation of the settlement. Among the six million settlers, primarily of European origin, only a handful are genuinely anti-Zionist; after a long personal journey to free themselves from indoctrination, they consider themselves Palestinians, their "Israeli" identity being merely the product of an imposed necessity. It can therefore be stated that virtually the entire society of the Zionist entity is a settler society because, despite internal dissension, it supports a colonial regime that it does not question and upon which its privileges and material conditions are based. Those who do not grasp the imperialist stage, nor the fundamental nature of this replacement colonization, cannot understand or accept this evident reality.
Obviously, this analysis can be unsettling and trap some in a difficult contradiction. One might initially welcome this achievement, this revelation that helps in the fight against the actions of the Zionist colonial state and its Western imperialist backers. But then one realizes that this supposed capacity for self-reflection is intrinsically part of the system at work within the pariah state, supported by an overwhelming majority of the settler population. And, as one understands, the filmmakers, however respectable they may be, are in fact the guarantors of an unreformable state. This forces all sincere supporters of the liberation of Palestine to confront the only path that will lead to an end to the horror of this unfolding genocide: the dismantling of the genocidal Zionist colonial entity .